32 bit files -> 24 bit
-
- gettin' sounds
- Posts: 144
- Joined: Mon Nov 03, 2003 4:17 pm
32 bit files -> 24 bit
I'm mixing a record for a band in PT... They recorded it in Cool Edit Pro, and have given me raw 32 bit .wav files. What's the best way to convert the files to 24 bit? I've seen the Awave Audio software, but I'm on a mac. . .
I know QT can deal with 32 bit files, but I'm worried about dithering.
Thanks in advance.
I know QT can deal with 32 bit files, but I'm worried about dithering.
Thanks in advance.
-
- buyin' gear
- Posts: 514
- Joined: Mon Mar 08, 2004 2:36 am
im not a big mac guy but, 32 is the internal rate, not the i/o rate (24 or 16).
different.
shouldn't be anything to worry about. except converting to .aiff right? while opening it in whatever you find to convert it to aiff, check the file properties and find out if its 24bit or 16bit. then if you need to get it to 24 from 16 your still fine and dithering might be a good thing. do it with and without and see what you like best.
btw there is no such thing as a 32bit I/O. well not yet anyway.
different.
shouldn't be anything to worry about. except converting to .aiff right? while opening it in whatever you find to convert it to aiff, check the file properties and find out if its 24bit or 16bit. then if you need to get it to 24 from 16 your still fine and dithering might be a good thing. do it with and without and see what you like best.
btw there is no such thing as a 32bit I/O. well not yet anyway.
-
- speech impediment
- Posts: 4270
- Joined: Tue Aug 12, 2003 5:31 pm
- Location: Norman, OK
- Contact:
-
- buyin' gear
- Posts: 514
- Joined: Mon Mar 08, 2004 2:36 am
32 bit is the internal file structure used for reading and storing the file and other internal operations. xp is a 32 bit OS. the 64bit version was just released.
this has absolutely nothing to do with the analog to digital conversion process.
"but, there IS such a thing as a 32bit .wav file, which some apps don't support."
which is why i pointed toward a file format convertion app, not a rate convertion app
this has absolutely nothing to do with the analog to digital conversion process.
"but, there IS such a thing as a 32bit .wav file, which some apps don't support."
which is why i pointed toward a file format convertion app, not a rate convertion app
-
- gettin' sounds
- Posts: 144
- Joined: Mon Nov 03, 2003 4:17 pm
-
- speech impediment
- Posts: 4270
- Joined: Tue Aug 12, 2003 5:31 pm
- Location: Norman, OK
- Contact:
aside from your desire to educate everyone on the obvious and well-known fact that there are no 32 bit converters in existence, what the hell does "internal file structure" and i/o have to do with this situation?crashsick wrote:32 bit is the internal file structure used for reading and storing the file and other internal operations. xp is a 32 bit OS. the 64bit version was just released.
this has absolutely nothing to do with the analog to digital conversion process.
"but, there IS such a thing as a 32bit .wav file, which some apps don't support."
which is why i pointed toward a file format convertion app, not a rate convertion app
he's dealing with files saved as "32bit .wav" files.
the file properties should indicate that it's a 32bit .wav file. I don't know any app that will tell you in "file properties" what resolution the file was converted at. The app will list the resolution that the file was SAVED at, in this case, 32bit.while opening it in whatever you find to convert it to aiff, check the file properties and find out if its 24bit or 16bit.
-
- buyin' gear
- Posts: 514
- Joined: Mon Mar 08, 2004 2:36 am
"what the hell does internal file structure" and i/o have to do with this situation? "
actually this is the only situation
he asked if he had to convert a file from 32bit to 24bit. but this doesn't make any sense at all, since the 2 numbers have nothing to do with each other. 32 represents one thing and 24 another. they?re just numbers.
32bit is the rate and size at which a file is stored and processed inside of the computer.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/32bit
and 24bit is the rate and size at which actual audio is converted from analog to digital and back to analog. this is the resolution at which the capture and reproduction happen. sort of like the numbers of photos take in a second, the more you have the better the motion looks (sounds). it has nothing at all to do with how this file is going to be arranged on a hard drive for instance. which has a 32 bit file structure. a formatted hard drive is just a big grid and its holes are 32 bits in size, depending on how it is formatted.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analog_to_ ... conversion
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WAV
its sort of like asking if he has to turn an apple blue in order to cut it into 10 pieces.
and it was not obvious to him as he is the one how asked the question. so i thought i would let him know he was looking at the problem incorrectly.
a bit is just a number used in computers, and just because they both have the word "bit" attached to them does not mean that they are the same in any way, shape, or form other then that they are numbers.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bit
"the file properties should indicate that it's a 32bit .wav file. I don't know any app that will tell you in "file properties" what resolution the file was converted at. The app will list the resolution that the file was SAVED at, in this case, 32bit."
this is simply not true. if you are running xp for instance and you right click on a .wav file and click properties, then click the summary tab at the top of the window, then click advanced. it will show you the bit rate (kbps), audio sample size (16 - 24bit), channels (stereo-mono), audio sample rate (khz), and the audio format (pcm or something). almost every single audio program i have ever used has this option, even windows media. in sound forge you just right click on the wave image and you get the same thing
all the macs i have on hand are older then crap and haven't been used in years, so im not sure how i would it is done on one, but i know its there. maybe click file info or properties or something inside of an audio programs drop down menu.
he simply needs to find a program that will convert the file from .wav to .aiff and thats it.
something like wavelab will work.
http://www.steinberg.de/displaydoc_sb40 ... vision_id=
but im sure there is something that is freeware that will do it too, maybe check here http://www.macmusic.org/softs/?lang=EN
after this then he can figure out if its 16 or 24bit and then decide if he needs to convert from 16 to 24 or 24 to 16.
time for me to get some sleep,
steve
actually this is the only situation
he asked if he had to convert a file from 32bit to 24bit. but this doesn't make any sense at all, since the 2 numbers have nothing to do with each other. 32 represents one thing and 24 another. they?re just numbers.
32bit is the rate and size at which a file is stored and processed inside of the computer.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/32bit
and 24bit is the rate and size at which actual audio is converted from analog to digital and back to analog. this is the resolution at which the capture and reproduction happen. sort of like the numbers of photos take in a second, the more you have the better the motion looks (sounds). it has nothing at all to do with how this file is going to be arranged on a hard drive for instance. which has a 32 bit file structure. a formatted hard drive is just a big grid and its holes are 32 bits in size, depending on how it is formatted.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analog_to_ ... conversion
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WAV
its sort of like asking if he has to turn an apple blue in order to cut it into 10 pieces.
and it was not obvious to him as he is the one how asked the question. so i thought i would let him know he was looking at the problem incorrectly.
a bit is just a number used in computers, and just because they both have the word "bit" attached to them does not mean that they are the same in any way, shape, or form other then that they are numbers.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bit
"the file properties should indicate that it's a 32bit .wav file. I don't know any app that will tell you in "file properties" what resolution the file was converted at. The app will list the resolution that the file was SAVED at, in this case, 32bit."
this is simply not true. if you are running xp for instance and you right click on a .wav file and click properties, then click the summary tab at the top of the window, then click advanced. it will show you the bit rate (kbps), audio sample size (16 - 24bit), channels (stereo-mono), audio sample rate (khz), and the audio format (pcm or something). almost every single audio program i have ever used has this option, even windows media. in sound forge you just right click on the wave image and you get the same thing
all the macs i have on hand are older then crap and haven't been used in years, so im not sure how i would it is done on one, but i know its there. maybe click file info or properties or something inside of an audio programs drop down menu.
he simply needs to find a program that will convert the file from .wav to .aiff and thats it.
something like wavelab will work.
http://www.steinberg.de/displaydoc_sb40 ... vision_id=
but im sure there is something that is freeware that will do it too, maybe check here http://www.macmusic.org/softs/?lang=EN
after this then he can figure out if its 16 or 24bit and then decide if he needs to convert from 16 to 24 or 24 to 16.
time for me to get some sleep,
steve
-
- gettin' sounds
- Posts: 144
- Joined: Mon Nov 03, 2003 4:17 pm
Actually that's not the problem at all. Pro tools will work with .wav files just fine.he simply needs to find a program that will convert the file from .wav to .aiff and thats it.
My problem is I'm thoroughly confused by Cool Edit Pro's "32 bit" audio files. The guy that recorded it says he has an option to record at 16 bits or 32 bits in CEP, no 24 bit option.
Any Cool Edit users here?
Thanks again...
-
- buyin' gear
- Posts: 514
- Joined: Mon Mar 08, 2004 2:36 am
i used it years and years ago it when it was just cool edit and it was shareware. and followed it up to the first pro version. shit im dating myself. if you only had the option of 16 and 32 then it is just and old version that was only capable of 16 bit audio. and the 32 once again is the internal depth. so its a 16 bit file and if PT is reading it and it sounds good then your fine as it is. unless you want to convert to 24 bit. if thats the case and you are still wondering whether or not to dither while upsampling then try a track with and without and see if one sounds better then the other to you. if you have several dithering options, try them too and see what you like (maybe just do short sections by cutting it if it takes a long time). but if its only a couple of tracks that you will be adding a lot to, then most of the difference made with dithering will not matter when it come time to mix. unless there are really quite passages or fades with the track(s) in question.
-
- buyin' gear
- Posts: 514
- Joined: Mon Mar 08, 2004 2:36 am
a thought just popped into my head as i was trying to fall asleep. by your friend saying that he only had the option of 16 and 32bit in that same small tab ( i assume thats what he meant). that means that that version of cool edit came out around the time of the xp launch. so it was compatible with both 98 and xp. 98 had a 16bit file structure and xp the 32bit (xp is backwards compatible, 16 fits into 32). also that he is using xp now because he was given the option of the two. so he saved it as 32bit for storage under xp, but we still don't know what the actual audio bit rate is. that is if this is actually true. so i would guess 16, but you should try and find that file info option in protools or something to make sure. if you can't then try to convert it to 24 and see what it says. it might say it is already 24 then you will know for sure.
back to sleep
back to sleep
-
- speech impediment
- Posts: 4270
- Joined: Tue Aug 12, 2003 5:31 pm
- Location: Norman, OK
- Contact:
the file is a 32 bit .wav file. you're confusing the hell out of this guy.
I just launched my windows xp machine to verify it. I checked the summary tab in the properties for a 32 bit .wav file that I had previously created with Cubase. Sure enough, Windows says, "Audio sample size: 32 bit."
I understand the difference between the internal resolution of a particular app on a particular os, and the bit depth of a/d and d/a conversion. What you don't seem to understand is that there IS SUCH THING AS A 32 bit .wav file. It might not be in Wikipedia yet. But, I know that Cubase, Nuendo, and Cool Edit Pro offer this option. I know that DP and PT do not. I'm not sure about other apps.
I realize that since there are no 32 bit converters available, there will be no more than 24 bits of actual information contained in a 32 bit .wav file. It's my understanding that Cubase and Nuendo offer this option to account for post conversion, pre-harddrive plug-in processing. I don't track with plug-ins, so I usually just leave it at 24 bit. But, if you select 32 bit, and record something, it does indeed record it as a 32bit .wav file. A file that will open in Cubase, Nuendo, Wavelab, or Cool Edit, but not in PT or DP.
Why would this person's version of Cool Edit give the option to select between different internal resolutions? The option that the client is seeing on Cool Edit is the bit resolution at which to save .wav files. I have no idea why it doesn't offer a 24 bit option.
I just launched my windows xp machine to verify it. I checked the summary tab in the properties for a 32 bit .wav file that I had previously created with Cubase. Sure enough, Windows says, "Audio sample size: 32 bit."
I understand the difference between the internal resolution of a particular app on a particular os, and the bit depth of a/d and d/a conversion. What you don't seem to understand is that there IS SUCH THING AS A 32 bit .wav file. It might not be in Wikipedia yet. But, I know that Cubase, Nuendo, and Cool Edit Pro offer this option. I know that DP and PT do not. I'm not sure about other apps.
I realize that since there are no 32 bit converters available, there will be no more than 24 bits of actual information contained in a 32 bit .wav file. It's my understanding that Cubase and Nuendo offer this option to account for post conversion, pre-harddrive plug-in processing. I don't track with plug-ins, so I usually just leave it at 24 bit. But, if you select 32 bit, and record something, it does indeed record it as a 32bit .wav file. A file that will open in Cubase, Nuendo, Wavelab, or Cool Edit, but not in PT or DP.
Why would this person's version of Cool Edit give the option to select between different internal resolutions? The option that the client is seeing on Cool Edit is the bit resolution at which to save .wav files. I have no idea why it doesn't offer a 24 bit option.
-
- speech impediment
- Posts: 4270
- Joined: Tue Aug 12, 2003 5:31 pm
- Location: Norman, OK
- Contact:
Cubase and Nuendo are the only programs that I know for mac that support 32 bit .wav files. There are probably more.kikocoolray wrote:Actually that's not the problem at all. Pro tools will work with .wav files just fine.he simply needs to find a program that will convert the file from .wav to .aiff and thats it.
My problem is I'm thoroughly confused by Cool Edit Pro's "32 bit" audio files. The guy that recorded it says he has an option to record at 16 bits or 32 bits in CEP, no 24 bit option.
Any Cool Edit users here?
Thanks again...
The easiest route for you would be to find someone with Wavelab on a PC that could convert all of the 32bit files to 24 bit for you. Wavelab could do it as a "batch process" and knock 'em all out pretty quick.
Good luck.
-
- gettin' sounds
- Posts: 144
- Joined: Mon Nov 03, 2003 4:17 pm
Thanks-- this is actually the info I was after in the first place...Cubase and Nuendo are the only programs that I know for mac that support 32 bit .wav files. There are probably more.
The easiest route for you would be to find someone with Wavelab on a PC that could convert all of the 32bit files to 24 bit for you. Wavelab could do it as a "batch process" and knock 'em all out pretty quick
I seem to recall reading that Quicktime could convert from 32 bit to 24 bit audio. Aside from the fact that this wouldn't be the speediest option, I'm concerned about downsampling without dithering.
What a pain in the ass.
-
- ass engineer
- Posts: 46
- Joined: Thu Nov 10, 2005 6:25 am
yes. i would imagine he should be able to convert without dithering, as there really is no information in the extra 8 bits, as the AD conversion hapened at 24 bits or less.subatomic pieces wrote:the file is a 32 bit .wav file. you're confusing the hell out of this guy.
I just launched my windows xp machine to verify it. I checked the summary tab in the properties for a 32 bit .wav file that I had previously created with Cubase. Sure enough, Windows says, "Audio sample size: 32 bit."
I realize that since there are no 32 bit converters available, there will be no more than 24 bits of actual information contained in a 32 bit .wav file. It's my understanding that Cubase and Nuendo offer this option to account for post conversion, pre-harddrive plug-in processing. I don't track with plug-ins, so I usually just leave it at 24 bit. But, if you select 32 bit, and record something, it does indeed record it as a 32bit .wav file. A file that will open in Cubase, Nuendo, Wavelab, or Cool Edit, but not in PT or DP.
-
- speech impediment
- Posts: 4270
- Joined: Tue Aug 12, 2003 5:31 pm
- Location: Norman, OK
- Contact:
but, the question is, does the conversion from 32bit to 24bit simply chop off those 8 empty bits? or is it more of a downsampling process where dither would be appropriate.sleep over jack wrote:yes. i would imagine he should be able to convert without dithering, as there really is no information in the extra 8 bits, as the AD conversion hapened at 24 bits or less.subatomic pieces wrote:the file is a 32 bit .wav file. you're confusing the hell out of this guy.
I just launched my windows xp machine to verify it. I checked the summary tab in the properties for a 32 bit .wav file that I had previously created with Cubase. Sure enough, Windows says, "Audio sample size: 32 bit."
I realize that since there are no 32 bit converters available, there will be no more than 24 bits of actual information contained in a 32 bit .wav file. It's my understanding that Cubase and Nuendo offer this option to account for post conversion, pre-harddrive plug-in processing. I don't track with plug-ins, so I usually just leave it at 24 bit. But, if you select 32 bit, and record something, it does indeed record it as a 32bit .wav file. A file that will open in Cubase, Nuendo, Wavelab, or Cool Edit, but not in PT or DP.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 48 guests