One Room Studio?
-
- takin' a dinner break
- Posts: 166
- Joined: Wed Jul 09, 2003 10:32 pm
- Location: Whittier, CA
- Contact:
One Room Studio?
Brethren,
Friends and e-friends have been convincing me to not build a an 8X11 control room within my 20X23 foot 2 car garage due to the acoustic limitations of such a small room. If I go without a control room, what ideas do you have for a mix position within the big room? Do any of you work in a 1 room space, do you dig it? or does anyone have pictures of a 1 room space?
I know I would build a vocal booth and have a couple of movable baffles - But I could only guess where the mix area would be.
Thanks for any suggestions
Chuck
http://droolbrothers.com
Friends and e-friends have been convincing me to not build a an 8X11 control room within my 20X23 foot 2 car garage due to the acoustic limitations of such a small room. If I go without a control room, what ideas do you have for a mix position within the big room? Do any of you work in a 1 room space, do you dig it? or does anyone have pictures of a 1 room space?
I know I would build a vocal booth and have a couple of movable baffles - But I could only guess where the mix area would be.
Thanks for any suggestions
Chuck
http://droolbrothers.com
-
- re-cappin' neve
- Posts: 639
- Joined: Sat Apr 17, 2004 8:58 pm
- Cellotron
- tinnitus
- Posts: 1025
- Joined: Mon Oct 13, 2003 9:49 pm
- Location: Brooklyn, New York
- Contact:
Coolest one room studio in the world has gotta be the Neve Room at Allaire -
http://www.allairestudios.com/studios/studios_neve.html
My friend Paul Mitchell just set up a really nice one room studio in the woods of Glen Spey (a couple hours outside NYC) - http://www.trickdogrecording.com
anyway -
My one room is set up for mastering -
but once in a blue moon I actually track in here too (usually just for my own projects recording "small" things like cello and other strings, vox, acoustic guitar, hand percussion - although I have indeed done some work for others in here - definitely not my forte though). Since it's really a mastering room I don't have a console - just a few pres that I can send to the Mytek AD's and then to the DAW - along with a few headphone amps for monitoring while tracking. I have a small wheelable computer cart for the DAW monitors/keyboard (with long cables that go to the computers setup in a walk-in closet space) - and my analog process chain is on a wheelable rack too - these usually get pushed to the side (out of the sweet spot) to make space for musicians & instruments.
It helps to get a nice pair of reference headphones (been digging the Ultrasone ProLine 650's I recently got), and you need to learn to hold really still while others are playing their parts (it's kind of like meditation practice if the tune is long!).
The advantage with the one room studio is that communication with the musicians is immediate as there is no need for talkback mics and no actual physical barriers. The disadvantage is that to really monitor what you are recording you generally have to record a scratch take and then do a playback - whereas in a traditional control room you can just have them play and be able to judge whether any adjustments in mic position is warranted immediately.
In general for bigger tracking projects I much prefer going into a "traditional" studio with a control room - but for more intimate recordings I find the one room option can actually be really nice for establishing a comfortable vibe.
Best regards,
Steve Berson
http://www.allairestudios.com/studios/studios_neve.html
My friend Paul Mitchell just set up a really nice one room studio in the woods of Glen Spey (a couple hours outside NYC) - http://www.trickdogrecording.com
anyway -
My one room is set up for mastering -
but once in a blue moon I actually track in here too (usually just for my own projects recording "small" things like cello and other strings, vox, acoustic guitar, hand percussion - although I have indeed done some work for others in here - definitely not my forte though). Since it's really a mastering room I don't have a console - just a few pres that I can send to the Mytek AD's and then to the DAW - along with a few headphone amps for monitoring while tracking. I have a small wheelable computer cart for the DAW monitors/keyboard (with long cables that go to the computers setup in a walk-in closet space) - and my analog process chain is on a wheelable rack too - these usually get pushed to the side (out of the sweet spot) to make space for musicians & instruments.
It helps to get a nice pair of reference headphones (been digging the Ultrasone ProLine 650's I recently got), and you need to learn to hold really still while others are playing their parts (it's kind of like meditation practice if the tune is long!).
The advantage with the one room studio is that communication with the musicians is immediate as there is no need for talkback mics and no actual physical barriers. The disadvantage is that to really monitor what you are recording you generally have to record a scratch take and then do a playback - whereas in a traditional control room you can just have them play and be able to judge whether any adjustments in mic position is warranted immediately.
In general for bigger tracking projects I much prefer going into a "traditional" studio with a control room - but for more intimate recordings I find the one room option can actually be really nice for establishing a comfortable vibe.
Best regards,
Steve Berson
-
- takin' a dinner break
- Posts: 166
- Joined: Wed Jul 09, 2003 10:32 pm
- Location: Whittier, CA
- Contact:
Steve,
Great references - that Neve room looks incredible. I am still a little worried about not being able to tweak eq or compression on the fly by listening through the monitors. But I am starting to see the advantages of the one room set up though and may try that, and if my hearing gets worse than it already is - I'll go to the original idea.
I am ready to rock - been remodeling my home for a year and a half and haven't recorded any records - I'm going nuts.....
If anyone has any more references or pics of a 1 room set up, please send my way.
Chuck
http://droolbrothers.com
Great references - that Neve room looks incredible. I am still a little worried about not being able to tweak eq or compression on the fly by listening through the monitors. But I am starting to see the advantages of the one room set up though and may try that, and if my hearing gets worse than it already is - I'll go to the original idea.
I am ready to rock - been remodeling my home for a year and a half and haven't recorded any records - I'm going nuts.....
If anyone has any more references or pics of a 1 room set up, please send my way.
Chuck
http://droolbrothers.com
- jrsgodfrey
- re-cappin' neve
- Posts: 735
- Joined: Wed May 07, 2003 7:19 am
- Location: Queens, NY
- Contact:
A couple I've worked at. Both great.
You either run some tape and listen back, or, like Brice did at Trout, run around with a pair of wireless islolating headphones.
http://www.ericambel.com/thestudio.htm
http://www.troutrecording.com/photo.html
You either run some tape and listen back, or, like Brice did at Trout, run around with a pair of wireless islolating headphones.
http://www.ericambel.com/thestudio.htm
http://www.troutrecording.com/photo.html
- sismofyt
- alignin' 24-trk
- Posts: 53
- Joined: Tue Mar 02, 2004 11:09 am
- Location: between rec & repro
- Contact:
daniel lanois is famous for that way of working.there's some articles at sound on sound with him and U2. good stuff, i remember
i like it too, and it's my prefered way of doing it. i've both had a big permanent place and rented houses and churches etc
you simply start working differently and tweak after recording. one trap is to start using the same mic positions everytime, because it 'works' or you're too lazy don't fall into that. experiment
when i've explained this way to bands/artist they can dig it. maybe it takes a bit longer to set up, but
NOTHING
i repeat
NOTHING
beats the direct contact between the people involved. that alone makes MUCH better records
and bleed is your friend, not enemy. it's free ambinece/verb, it's gooes everything together, it uhh. sounds real too, it's just something i cannot do without anymore
i'm enormously tired of 'studios' with their mostly same sounding rooms, layout and bloody lavalamp vibe
many musicians prefer to work this way also once they've tried varoius recording studios. i'm not really knocking down studios, they're great, but it certainly is not the only way to do it and imo it's not the best either for a lot of projects
renting a cheap house on the country side where you can bang away, is one helluva effective way of getting the stuff down on tape/hd that really matters
recording outside is also very nice. every instrument sounds much different, when you suddenly loose a boatload of room resonance, modes and waves
just my two kroner
i like it too, and it's my prefered way of doing it. i've both had a big permanent place and rented houses and churches etc
you simply start working differently and tweak after recording. one trap is to start using the same mic positions everytime, because it 'works' or you're too lazy don't fall into that. experiment
when i've explained this way to bands/artist they can dig it. maybe it takes a bit longer to set up, but
NOTHING
i repeat
NOTHING
beats the direct contact between the people involved. that alone makes MUCH better records
and bleed is your friend, not enemy. it's free ambinece/verb, it's gooes everything together, it uhh. sounds real too, it's just something i cannot do without anymore
i'm enormously tired of 'studios' with their mostly same sounding rooms, layout and bloody lavalamp vibe
many musicians prefer to work this way also once they've tried varoius recording studios. i'm not really knocking down studios, they're great, but it certainly is not the only way to do it and imo it's not the best either for a lot of projects
renting a cheap house on the country side where you can bang away, is one helluva effective way of getting the stuff down on tape/hd that really matters
recording outside is also very nice. every instrument sounds much different, when you suddenly loose a boatload of room resonance, modes and waves
just my two kroner
- sismofyt
- alignin' 24-trk
- Posts: 53
- Joined: Tue Mar 02, 2004 11:09 am
- Location: between rec & repro
- Contact:
here's some stuff to read:
http://www.soundonsound.com/sos/1994_ar ... 892246aa84
http://www.soundonsound.com/sos/1994_ar ... 892246aa84
the way monitoring is handled is espcially note worthy, i think
and those records mentioned sure sound kick ass to me
http://www.soundonsound.com/sos/1994_ar ... 892246aa84
http://www.soundonsound.com/sos/1994_ar ... 892246aa84
the way monitoring is handled is espcially note worthy, i think
and those records mentioned sure sound kick ass to me
Chuck
Try and get a symetrical set-up for your monitors, at least side to side. One rule of thumb I've heard is to place yourself and your speakers at the thirds or fifths positions relative to any dimension, and not to setup at the quarters or halves. For an example, if your room was 100 ft. long (don't you wish), the good spots for placement would be 20, 33, 40 (you get the idea) feet. I think the advantage is in not exciting the modes of the room.
Frank
Try and get a symetrical set-up for your monitors, at least side to side. One rule of thumb I've heard is to place yourself and your speakers at the thirds or fifths positions relative to any dimension, and not to setup at the quarters or halves. For an example, if your room was 100 ft. long (don't you wish), the good spots for placement would be 20, 33, 40 (you get the idea) feet. I think the advantage is in not exciting the modes of the room.
Frank
- Electro-Voice 664
- re-cappin' neve
- Posts: 745
- Joined: Sun Dec 07, 2003 8:48 pm
- Location: Washington
- Contact:
I have a room with similar dimensions as your garage. I had a small control room and it sucked. Especially with a full band hanging out all day, in a small room, with bad ventilation. Now I have one larger room and I?m much happier. I wear earplugs for loud things. The single room makes working fast. And the room sounds, looks, and functions better. You can check out some pics at www.wintershed.com
My vote>stay open
My vote>stay open
"Play ethnicky jazz to parade your snazz. On your five grand stereo."
- ;ivlunsdystf
- ghost haunting audio students
- Posts: 3290
- Joined: Mon Oct 18, 2004 7:15 am
- Location: The Great Frontier of the Southern Anoka Sand Plain
- Contact:
In my limited experiences dealing with control rooms, I have noted that a control room drastically increases the odds of psychic warfare between collaborators. The presence of such a room enables factions to form within the larger group by making it possible for two parties to discuss a third party in the absence of the third party.
We probably all have had the experience of playing music while watching others talk about our playing/sound through a control room window but being unable to hear what they are saying. I find it very unnerving. They might just be talking about the latest issue of People magazine or something, but it feeds one's paranoia all the same.
Maybe I'm just hypercaffeinated and paranoid.
We probably all have had the experience of playing music while watching others talk about our playing/sound through a control room window but being unable to hear what they are saying. I find it very unnerving. They might just be talking about the latest issue of People magazine or something, but it feeds one's paranoia all the same.
Maybe I'm just hypercaffeinated and paranoid.
- jrsgodfrey
- re-cappin' neve
- Posts: 735
- Joined: Wed May 07, 2003 7:19 am
- Location: Queens, NY
- Contact:
- Electro-Voice 664
- re-cappin' neve
- Posts: 745
- Joined: Sun Dec 07, 2003 8:48 pm
- Location: Washington
- Contact:
- scott anthony
- suffering 'studio suck'
- Posts: 472
- Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:00 pm
- Location: jersey
- Contact:
-
- takin' a dinner break
- Posts: 166
- Joined: Wed Jul 09, 2003 10:32 pm
- Location: Whittier, CA
- Contact:
Man - you guys are just too cool. Wintershed's studio looks like a great and comfy place to record. I kinda don't like studios that look like dental offices. The garagier - the better IMO.
Tatortot is soooo right on about the faction theory. They can't talk smack about each other if they're (we're) all in one big happy room - thus creating a work together vibe - genius.
This decision will save me a few hundred bucks so maybe I can use the scratch on some clean socks, porn or an RE 20.
Chuck
http://droolbrothers.com
Tatortot is soooo right on about the faction theory. They can't talk smack about each other if they're (we're) all in one big happy room - thus creating a work together vibe - genius.
This decision will save me a few hundred bucks so maybe I can use the scratch on some clean socks, porn or an RE 20.
Chuck
http://droolbrothers.com
- judecca
- takin' a dinner break
- Posts: 163
- Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2004 12:57 pm
- Location: Peoria Flippin' Illinois
- Contact:
i had a converted oversize 2 stall garage for about three years. i agree with what's been said about everyone being in one room. also, if i needed to move the guitar cab mic, i simply got up and moved it...30 seconds and we're listening to the results. especially a time saver when dealing with a multiple mic'ed instrument, like drums or a leslie. the down side is your monitoring situation during tracking. 1. it's hard to differentiate between the source sound in the room and whats actually going to tape (or hd). and 2. often to compensate for number 1 you may end up cranking your phones to hear anything through them.
i found it pretty tiring on the ear. i never quite got this situation resolved before i built a new place that had a control room. given the size you've got...i totally recommend a one room design. just be careful of the ears.
ryan
i found it pretty tiring on the ear. i never quite got this situation resolved before i built a new place that had a control room. given the size you've got...i totally recommend a one room design. just be careful of the ears.
ryan
"what burns metal, burns hands"
Tonelab Studios
Advanced Audio & Lighting Systems
ryan@tonelabstudios.com
www.tonelabstudios.com
309.691.7105
Tonelab Studios
Advanced Audio & Lighting Systems
ryan@tonelabstudios.com
www.tonelabstudios.com
309.691.7105
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 40 guests