Will mix for free.

Dot
pushin' record
Posts: 272
Joined: Fri Jul 04, 2003 4:44 am
Location: NY

Re: Will mix for free.

Post by Dot » Fri Jul 16, 2004 11:30 pm

I've got friends who have boats that cost well over $100,000. And they take people out in them all the time JUST FOR FUN. Just for the hell of it. For free. Just because they love to be out on their boats and enjoy the company of other people.

It's called a HOBBY.

Are they threatening the "boating industry"?

Adam, I salute you and your business model. And someone like you clearly stands out and above the pack by obviously making it attractive to work with you. [ Even this topic has gotten far more replies than other topics in the TO Classifieds. ] That can lead to great things.

Even someone like George Massenburg has commented that some of the very best stuff he's ever done were freebies.

Cracks me up that anyone would be threatened by what you're doing. Ha!

Adam, please stop by Studio Forums any time. Not only is it free, but we've given away thousands of dollars worth of gear to members.
djui5 wrote:
It's people like you who make it hard for people like me to charge what I do for my work....
djui5, perhaps it's people like you who make it hard for people like you to charge what you do for your work.
Dan Richards
Pro Studio Reviews

User avatar
Brian
resurrected
Posts: 2254
Joined: Mon Jun 02, 2003 6:00 pm
Location: corner of your eye
Contact:

Re: Will mix for free.

Post by Brian » Tue Jul 20, 2004 9:10 am

Rock on, Dan! Rock on!
Harumph!

User avatar
anewman
gimme a little kick & snare
Posts: 77
Joined: Sun Dec 28, 2003 9:01 pm
Location: Chicago, IL
Contact:

Re: Will mix for free.

Post by anewman » Thu Jul 22, 2004 11:54 am

Dan,

Understand that by giving away gear, you're making it hard for guitar center to sell gear. =)

-Adam
I'm a recordist; engineers have degrees.

bigtoe
deaf.
Posts: 1776
Joined: Tue May 13, 2003 5:13 am

Re: Will mix for free.

Post by bigtoe » Fri Jul 30, 2004 7:10 am

i do stuff for free mainly cuz when i try to charge for better projects they end up going to a place for free...it's self-defeating but what can you do?

in any other business it would be called undercutting the market...and would be illegal...i guess a hobby is fine as that's how i look at it as well...but just straight up freebeing it is just kinda selfish...i wouldn't feel threatened in chicago but i'd be like - 'oh - that guy with the free neotek.' not criticizing but to me free is for mackieland...you start stepping up into a pspace and hardcore gear like that you should probably think of the folks with hardcore gear around ya...that's thinking about the community too.

here's a good story - i had recorded an EP for a band and they wanted to mix with another guy - no problem! here ya go. well the guy offered to re-record everything for free at his 24 track studio as long as he got production credit...nice. i charged the band 175 for the weekend at a borrowed spot with an 8 track and it sounded great. i was happy for the band but definitely never worked with the studio again...so there's kind of a right way to do free...not saying you are or aren't but just commenting.

Mike

edit - ps - went to your site. boy it would be a lot cooler if you put what you get out of this. do you really expect people to think you're your mr. charity? you're leveling the playing field for musicians? it's kind of nausiating, actually. sorry. -Mike

User avatar
Brian
resurrected
Posts: 2254
Joined: Mon Jun 02, 2003 6:00 pm
Location: corner of your eye
Contact:

Re: Will mix for free.

Post by Brian » Fri Jul 30, 2004 5:07 pm

I saw your ad, you should be ashamed of yourself. Anyone who buys that much gear and doesn't charge is already rich and doesn't see their behaviour as affecting anyone else's, like the guy who does this for a living and is trying to continue to feed his child with a chronic illness the only way he knows how. It isn't so much that you're taking a sandwich outta his kid's mouth or medicine, but, how your behaviour is affecting a small market of people who make a living with similar gear. You are the opposite of the collective bargaining agreement. Oh I just love to hear about how this rich guy accidentally fucked everything up in a market and accidentally destroyed what took years to set up and effort to run daily to feed children, yeah, what your parents are obviously still doing for you. Well, some of us out here are parents and you are the opposite of help. Please, get some self worth and charge some money, or, sell your gear and become a DJ because if you can't make money=there's no market for you in this line of BUSINESS. If you don't charge, where does your money for new gear come from? You're picture is too young to have gotten a retirement package.
Ya know, I used to get approached to do a mix for free, when I was INTERNING at SOMEONE ELSE'S studio. Now when I get asked that I say "BLOW ME! or better yet, DON'T"
It's simple You have a talent for this and you go make money or you don't have any talent and you don't make money. School won't get you "an ear", you gotta have that to start with, really. You have too much time and too much money on your hands, act like you have a soul and some charactar and find a poor talented audio school grad , partner up and make some money. You can only piss in the pond so many time before no one will swim in it and everyone comments about the smell, some will refer to your pond as "the toilet".
Harumph!

User avatar
Brian
resurrected
Posts: 2254
Joined: Mon Jun 02, 2003 6:00 pm
Location: corner of your eye
Contact:

Re: Will mix for free.

Post by Brian » Sat Jul 31, 2004 9:33 am

As for working for free:Joined: 02 Jun 2003
Posts: 47
Posted: Fri 30.07.04, 7:07 pm?? ?Post subject: Re: Will mix for free.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
No amount of writing "I'm doing it because I love it" will desguize you low self worth and the fact that you live at home with your parents and they're paying for your "habit", to shut you up.

As for "Funny how you don't hear anyone bitching about TapeOp being free.":
They sell ads to advertizers! Ads ain't free! See, someone is trying to make a buck with TapeOp.

As for: "Since its cheaper to build a small recording room then it is to pay for recording time its no wonder the cost of recording fell through the floor."
Only if you really don't care about quality till you "figure out" what you're doing, which takes time. Little Equation: You're born naked, you buy shit, some of it you wanna keep, you die, all your crap and your naked body get left behind. ALL YOU HAD WAS YOUR TIME.

As for:"I do stuff for free all the time.

I feel like an idiot everytime I do."
Well put!

As for: "Why is everyone always kicking the little guy. "
Don't be fooled, he ain't the little guy, the litrtle guy charges.

Whats with getting on anewman's case he's probably doing this to gain a lot of experience so he can charge later. "
That's what internships are for, that and building a client base.

People aren't born to mix."
Oh, yeah!?!

As For: "Have you even heard Guided by Voices, Elliott Smith or Grandaddy?? They're the tip of an iceberg. They realised the mistake of thinking they had to be in a studio to make recordings of their VERY talented songs and ideas. They realised that a 4 track can be all you ever need. "
Doing it for your own band and getting a Grammy and spoiling a market are two different issues, anewman is hiring himself out foir free, not just recording his own stuff. Big difference.

As for: "Seems a bit odd to me for fedderman to be so threatened by home recordists and people who wish to do things for free etc. If somebody wants to do something for free, be it for fun, experience, whatever, i don't see what business it is of anybody else."
I guess your actions never affect a community of people either, oh, you just never thouight about that. What if TapeOp stopped selling ads, then you wouldn't get your mag unless oyu paid for it, but, where's the money going to come from if YOU are recording for free,? MOM and DAD.
Recording for free is fine, if you are interning in someone else's studio, where someone can teach you proffessional techniques that aren't "in the manual" (and there are lots). Anyone who thinks buying a bunch of gear and working for free is good for "anewman" is doing anewman a great dis-service. The fact is that he won't learn how to do a better job in a reasonable amount of time without it and he'll miss out on a lot of opportunity to pick up[ good clients that pay and appreciate contributing to his cause monatarily, the basis of our country. We ain't socialists.

As for: "I once worked for a guy that tought me a really important lesson. He told me that "if you work for free, your work is worthless".
ROCK ON!

As for: "Maybe he should be told that giving freely isn't worthless, it's priceless. "
Try paying your studio electricity with a "priceless" check. It starts a whole new dynamic in your attitude toward money, especially when you get a whole $7 a day to clean up trash in an orange jumpsuit for a week.

As For: " I've got friends who have boats that cost well over $100,000. And they take people out in them all the time JUST FOR FUN. Just for the hell of it. For free. Just because they love to be out on their boats and enjoy the company of other people.

It's called a HOBBY.

Are they threatening the "boating industry"? "
If you mean "water taxi industry and if they run their boat outta the same dock as a commercial water-taxi operation, yes they are.
"Even someone like George Massenburg has commented that some of the very best stuff he's ever done were freebies. "
George has done a whole lot more stuff for big buck$ and I bet if you ask him to do your project for free right now he hangs up on you.

"Understand that by giving away gear, you're making it hard for guitar center to sell gear. =) "
Do ya think he originally gets the gear through GTCR? They give away one piece of gear, not the whole store.
You are young, you need to get some perspective on your goal, make a better path that is more condusive to your success, not someone else's at your expense, that's for interns.
Nope, the freebie guys don't affect my business, more likely people who can't pay or try to haggle at the end of a project when they overspent on lunch during the sessions.

You are a part of the community of studios in your area whether you like it or not. You just don't have enough confidence to charge, yet. Charge anyway. You'll feel a lot better about yourself. Just cuz your parents got bucks doesn't mean you can't or shouldn't make your own.
A lot of guys in this biz had overbearing parents, it spawns musicians and engineers, it doesn't have to own you.
Do an internship, (even while you do your own studio biz) get some clients and solicit all the help you can from the guy who's engineering the sessions you intern on (before or after the session) and pay attention, do what they say. An internship played right is waaaaayyy more valuable than going to school or owning gear.
For instance, after interning at a great studio, I engineered a demo for a band. We tracked drums live to 2track dat at a cheap studio, then with one microphone (Beyer M-500) and an old 8-track & an 8channel mixer dumped and overdubbed in my living room and got a deal with Capitol.
Clients seek me out. Why? ""TALENT!" I hope, cuz, I ain't that cheap.
It ain't the gear. I can work anywhere. You can do this and you can get an ear if you don't have one, there are actually courses for an engineers ears, a producer's ear is much more subjective. I think it could be taught though. It won't be in the manual of some gear.
Harumph!

User avatar
Brian
resurrected
Posts: 2254
Joined: Mon Jun 02, 2003 6:00 pm
Location: corner of your eye
Contact:

Re: Will mix for free.

Post by Brian » Sat Jul 31, 2004 9:42 am

Oh, yeah, there's a big deal of difference between "FREE" and "ON SPEC" typically appr%4 of gross with a buy-out clause. Working on spec is better than free, if you really like the project and you think it'll go somewhere or that you might be able to push it, have the artists sign a spec agreement. Could pay off, could tank. It's up to you.
Harumph!

OM15.2
suffering 'studio suck'
Posts: 436
Joined: Thu Feb 05, 2004 3:45 pm
Location: tripping security alarms

Re: Will mix for free.

Post by OM15.2 » Sun Aug 01, 2004 11:27 pm

Brian wrote: Nope, the freebie guys don't affect my business
oh that's good. For a minute there I though you had really taken this personally.

And as for
Brain wrote:....appreciate contributing to his cause monatarily, the basis of our country. We ain't socialists

WTF? Where does it say in your constitution that your society is about capitalism? where does it say that that's the basis of your country? Remember freedom of speach & religion and democracy? that's the basis of your country. This guy can charge or not charge, IT'S UP TO HIM! it's his right to choose. Don't bring up socialist labeling bullshit.

It cracks me up that for MONTHS people have been argueing with this guy saying he should be charging and because of this for 7 MONTHS now this thread has been bumped to the top of this forum. The irony may be lost on you that since early January anyone visting this board that lives in this guys area is going to see "Will mix for free" and that this guy may have got jobs because of it, but I think it's just perfect.

Really this guy can mix and charge or NOT charge. It's his decision. That's life mate, might not always go the you want but you've got to get over it.

bigtoe
deaf.
Posts: 1776
Joined: Tue May 13, 2003 5:13 am

Re: Will mix for free.

Post by bigtoe » Mon Aug 02, 2004 5:07 am

"No amount of writing "I'm doing it because I love it" will desguize you low self worth and the fact that you live at home with your parents and they're paying for your "habit", to shut you up."

i wouldn't go this far.

i'll tell you - on the pro free tip - studio owners are more than happy to have you work for free in an internship or a poorly paid assist spot. what makes them think you should not be working for free gaining experience? the industry did it to itself...the macho 'you can't hack it thing' is used in kitchens as well..."i can't hack it? for 8 buck an hour? no sweat man! i wouldn't want to! see ya!"

"Really this guy can mix and charge or NOT charge. It's his decision."

Well it is and it isn't...if yer in a buinsess market there are laws against unfair competition and rules regulating how you compete in a market with others. i doubt anyone will give a shit about this dude legally...but in general it is in pretty poor taste to undercut for business...and to say yer morally higher than folks who are charging is kind of foul as well...i don't take offense to it but whoa man...

Mike

User avatar
Brian
resurrected
Posts: 2254
Joined: Mon Jun 02, 2003 6:00 pm
Location: corner of your eye
Contact:

Re: Will mix for free.

Post by Brian » Tue Aug 03, 2004 6:32 pm

Aw, bloddy hell mate, don't be such a wanker, British guy who lives nowhere near "the freebie", but, you got ticked because I wrote socialist. Sorry dude, the USA is like a different planet.
I didn't write "nasty socialist", I think it's a neat ideal however infrequently implemented and "we the people' aren't going to become socialists because it's "o.k.". You Brits have it down! We tried it over here and this country sucks at it's administration and at any kind of charade of any kind of government. Too much corruption.
Eventually the "lords" (tosspots) eat the "commoners' (us) over here no matter what anyone thinks, and quite often, they are eating "the soilant green" without even knowing (or caring to know) that what they're eating is made out of it. Now that's pathetic, but, true. Ignorant of others humanity, no sense of community that doesn't directly and primarily serve them.
In America, home of the idealistic yet impossible to achieve goal of the blabbernaught, if you start a business and you don't charge,,,you got three months max to clean you stuff outta wherever you have it because YOU ARE BROKE, unless mom and dad are funding you.
We HAVE NO DOLE, that's where it says we are capitalists and it's true. It's a harder world over here to feed yourself or your kids. Let alone the cost of medicine and the mammoth medical insurance scam.
In a perfect world where I don't need money and I don't even think of the day coming where I look into my un-insurable child's face and say, "sorry son, I did the best I could, but, you're gonna die, I have to work for free now, cuz some guy slowly eroded what little market we had by giving away for free what we charge for" and march down to the unemployment office to get turned down because I owned my own business and I meet the other engineers who are now outta work too, and we conspire to form a "boy band" (a'la Nsync) only we're too old now, so we settle on a tricycle store and selling peanuts to feed the birds, tupence, tupence a bag. (old money, sterling not decimal)
then I'll work for free cuz I love what I do and I've been doing it well since I was 15, and I'm a lot older now.
P.S. Trouble & strife is a scouser.
Harumph!

User avatar
Brian
resurrected
Posts: 2254
Joined: Mon Jun 02, 2003 6:00 pm
Location: corner of your eye
Contact:

Re: Will mix for free.

Post by Brian » Tue Aug 03, 2004 7:18 pm

they're paying for your "habit", to shut you up."

i wouldn't go this far.

i'll tell you - on the pro free tip - studio owners are more than happy to have you work for free in an internship or a poorly paid assist spot. what makes them think you should not be working for free gaining experience? the industry did it to itself...the macho 'you can't hack it thing' is used in kitchens as well..."i can't hack it? for 8 buck an hour? no sweat man! i wouldn't want to! see ya!"


I don't mean the "you can't hack it' internship, I mean the "working for someone without an attitude because you are a better negotiator (maybe some time for a project) and you want to learn how to do it right from a master and expand on that' internship. I had to move 1285 miles from home with $300 cash in my wallet and the promise of a job, a room, and an internship at a very desirable studio and I didn't know one person and I was 18. They started off by telling me I had to clean the toilet, I did, then organize the tape library, I did, then the safety library, I did, then the tech area, I did, then they showed me how to wrap a cable (most interns had quit by then , but, there were still 25 left) I had been wrapping cables for 3 years before that, apparently wrong. I now have 20 year old cables that work perfectly, because I now know how to wrap them without hurting them. Do You?
Then they showed me mic selection and use (lotsa Neumann mics you don't even hear about now) then aligning those old Studer 2"ers which weren't that old then, then outboard (stuff most engineers slobber over today) and the patchbay and how it all really worked and how to make a Neve 8068 run 48 tracks with two Studers and a "Shadow" syncbox (pre sbx80). I knew a lot going in, enough that I had already made money recording people for years, but, this was a whole new ballgame. Now I have that intangible knowing what to do when,,,happens that you can't get by yourself, you gotta have a mentor to get and a good one too. I spend most of my time recording and mixing, not fixing. I keep a flow reminiscent of using tape (not sync issues mind you) in an all digital studio.
I like the editing ability, but that's all. but I digress,,,,,
I slept very little, I worked a lot 2 shifts as a waiter interning in between and after shifts till 3 am. everyday possible. I put up 2" tapes of Billy Joel 16trk 2", Bruce Springsteen, Richie Havens, the Fama Allstars (Latino/Salsa) and lotsa others, other people's projects and mixed them and left masters on the manager's desk. Then came assisting. I found artists that recorded at Media Sound and mixed their stuff other places mainly for my reel. I'm not above doing an internship to learn a new form of recording technology. I re-interned to learn the alignment procedure and operation for the Studer A-827.
Funny though, when the digital stuff (not SSL which I interned a 3rd time to learn though I was already making $ on one) came out, like ProTool, heh heh, nobody wanted interns around, and engineers forgot how to mic things. Hired straight outta school and no internship.
I'm glad I did it. I'm not afraid to do any session. I shoulda paid them, I bet they don't argue with that. Anyway if this guy has M&P payin', why not get him an internship at a great place, maybe in his town, to learn what can't be taught any other way while he can afford it, the, turn him loose on stuff while he's still got the wear-with-all to spend some time on a project and I bet you get one stellar producer,,,or a big flop either way with better odds for success and a better sense of who he is in relation with his community.
Harumph!

User avatar
Brian
resurrected
Posts: 2254
Joined: Mon Jun 02, 2003 6:00 pm
Location: corner of your eye
Contact:

Re: Will mix for free.

Post by Brian » Tue Aug 03, 2004 7:37 pm

Oh, Yeah, that's what "check your ego at the door" means. It ain't about the $8/hr, it's about the music. That's not saying you mighta interned with a jerk, jus don't let that put you off, you're bigger than that.
Harumph!

bigtoe
deaf.
Posts: 1776
Joined: Tue May 13, 2003 5:13 am

Re: Will mix for free.

Post by bigtoe » Wed Aug 04, 2004 5:52 am

You are a riot. You come from a completely different era than this kid here and are obviously doing a different game. You look very music business. This is fine.

"working for someone without an attitude because you are a better negotiator (maybe some time for a project) and you want to learn how to do it right from a master and expand on that'

Trust me, I interned and assisted under some terrific peeps and I still do this when ever I have the chance?I don't see how you can call people out on such little information, but no biggie.

Later?
Mike
edit - change post.

User avatar
Brian
resurrected
Posts: 2254
Joined: Mon Jun 02, 2003 6:00 pm
Location: corner of your eye
Contact:

Re: Will mix for free.

Post by Brian » Wed Aug 04, 2004 6:55 am

I'm old and moldy and a little mean, but, only in sservice to others not myself.
I can tell you did an internship by your posts. Even back in the day, there were crappy internships where the newest guy new more than the owner. You could tell by how many people quit and how often.
Ya know, if the freebie has any chops, a smart thing for him to do would be to seek out a very high profile gig with no money in it and kick ass. That always goes a long way toward a big career, yep, I did that too, after my internship, heh heh heh.
Yah, I'm old, and I saw how the biz went down from $500k recording funds and big promo to $12k and no promo. It's probly lower than that now.
It's not "RAP'S" fault, but, somebody started doing rap demos in their home and the "bean counters" swarmed. You could get enough gear to do a rap album in your house for about $12k.
Then the "midi studios" that signed girl groups started popping up everywhere finding any check available and popping out demos cheap around $45k. Well the bean counters found out again and you could hear a great sucking noise.
The worst thing that happened after that was the labels bean counters started this thing about how they were ordinary people and they were good judges of talent. That and the missing money gave proffessional managers and "real" A& R guys heart attacks and strokes, and they started bailing like nobody's business. There were a few labels left doing real art, but, mostly affiliated minors.
So they had to hire new people. Well, the only people qualified to interview and instruct them had gone so any college kid with an in was in, regardless of ability(which most didn't have). Most of the producers that did some scouting were just midi studio /girl group guys looking for their next blowjob. Talent got rarer.
If you wanna see how bad it's gotten, go to a wedding or any club with a coverband, sit there for 5 years and see how few new tunes pop up on the set list from each of over 500 bands from 10 states. That's where the rubber meets the road in one place. Most of the songs you hear will be from the 70's, a few from the 80's, 4 or 5 from the nineties and nothing past the mellinia but hardcore. SAD. There's talent out there, no one is developing it. I remember one manager yelling on the phone to an A&R guy saying" I don't wanna develope this kid, give me something that's ready to go!" kinda says it all. She was a rich kid.
Harumph!

bigtoe
deaf.
Posts: 1776
Joined: Tue May 13, 2003 5:13 am

Re: Will mix for free.

Post by bigtoe » Wed Aug 04, 2004 8:13 am

Oh man - totally different world you are in?my internships were ok?nothing like that style of stuff with the 25 interns?I did want to try Battery in Chicago. Is that the place? Huge?.but the music I got into was much more independent so I went that route?the bands I record take offense to being 'groomed'?

It certainly is a problem - the internship thing - and now the free thing. maybe not a problem but definitely a 'situation.' It's hard and recording is like the hoola hoop right now so the few good spots there are are fewer still.

Eh?hard times?but worth it.

Mike

Locked

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 39 guests