This thread has hit on some interesting psychology/business. I think 'opening' up your kick drum sound is a great idea, especially for certain types of music. I recently started a thread in Recording Techniques about some of my observations on kick drum sounds on awesome records. I've put my sounds up against recordings I like and realized I was trying to get way more power in a kick drum sound than most (but not all) genres and mixes need. I realize a lot of time's recording gets 'oohs' and 'aaahs' less for 'power' and more for 'focus' and 'presence' (which people's ears tend to perceive as power/hugeness).Ryan Silva wrote:
I?ve used the standard d112, b52, 57 on inside kick quite a lot, all acceptable, but when I want to open up the kick and add deep lows I have turned to the aforementioned mics. I am pretty sure it's a combination of my inexperience, and at times poor placement. However my least expensive mic on that list (EHR1 ribbon) has given me the closest to what I?m hoping to achieve. (Same height as center kick about 3-4' away)
I put kick drums next to vocals for some of the easiest things to sound mediocre, and hardest to sound impressive.
I will say after renting a Neuman for a session, if you're matching the wrong mic for the instrument it will still sound weak. I was able to let go of my adolescent ideas about mic bling when I hit playback hearing someone sing into that Neuman and thinking "Nope, not awesome." On a different voice maybe.
I know people always say it, but if you don't like the sound you're getting the mic is one part. The other parts are what kind of drum you're micing, how much crap is inside it, how you tuned it, how your room sounds, what kind of preamp you're using. Maybe even in that order. I even discovered with another engineer how important the beater on the kick pedal is: plastic, wood, soft stuff. We came to the conclusion that those flat beaters that look like hammers, sound crappy when they hit the drum soft, and that a round beater is better for dynamic playing.
Meanwhile I've heard people mention the following for much enjoyed kick LDCs:
AT 4033, 4047, 4050
Blue Mouse
MXL Vsomething cheapo