Bottom snare mic as a room mic, and other small room tricks.
- Ryan Silva
- tinnitus
- Posts: 1229
- Joined: Sat Aug 07, 2004 6:46 pm
- Location: San Francisco
Bottom snare mic as a room mic, and other small room tricks.
It seems that so many drums recordings I get nowadays, whether they are mine or not, have pitiful sounding room mics tracks.
I bet like half the time I throw up room mics on drums they don?t get used, or I chose not to mix with the room tracks I?m given.
This is probably due to studios shrinking in size, providing a poorer environment to capture long reflections, resulting in washy small room reflections. (like I said, I too battle this when tracking)
In this case, the mother of invention has provided a lot of creativity out there. Like the room mics on the floor, a ?heart? mic placed above the kick drum, underheads, etc.
My favorite trick lately is side chaining the bottom snare mic, and processing the hell out of the tail; whether with a comp, or my personal favorite, Transient Designer.
How are you guys fairing lately?
I bet like half the time I throw up room mics on drums they don?t get used, or I chose not to mix with the room tracks I?m given.
This is probably due to studios shrinking in size, providing a poorer environment to capture long reflections, resulting in washy small room reflections. (like I said, I too battle this when tracking)
In this case, the mother of invention has provided a lot of creativity out there. Like the room mics on the floor, a ?heart? mic placed above the kick drum, underheads, etc.
My favorite trick lately is side chaining the bottom snare mic, and processing the hell out of the tail; whether with a comp, or my personal favorite, Transient Designer.
How are you guys fairing lately?
"Writing good songs is hard. recording is easy. "
MoreSpaceEcho
MoreSpaceEcho
- ott0bot
- dead but not forgotten
- Posts: 2023
- Joined: Thu Jan 15, 2009 4:54 pm
- Location: Downtown Phoenix
I think room mics in smaller spaces still work...but take a little more processing. Adding delay, smashing them, spring reverb, parallel compression, extreme eq, reamping, etc. I heard a suggestion from joel about getting better room sound by throwing up a cymbal or a sheet of metal on the far side of the room, and facing a mic at it for a sort of natural plate sound. I gotta try that.
Specifically regarding the bottom stnare mic...the Sunny Day Real Estate song "Days are Golden" on the "How it Feels..." album has a rad outro with a solo'd and crushed phasey bottom snare mic. Not much of a room mic...pretty much just the snares rattling and a bit of a feint kick sound. Musta been a super cardiod dynamic or something.
Also, I record drums in my living room....so you both can shut it.
Specifically regarding the bottom stnare mic...the Sunny Day Real Estate song "Days are Golden" on the "How it Feels..." album has a rad outro with a solo'd and crushed phasey bottom snare mic. Not much of a room mic...pretty much just the snares rattling and a bit of a feint kick sound. Musta been a super cardiod dynamic or something.
Also, I record drums in my living room....so you both can shut it.
- Ryan Silva
- tinnitus
- Posts: 1229
- Joined: Sat Aug 07, 2004 6:46 pm
- Location: San Francisco
ott0bot wrote:I think room mics in smaller spaces still work...but take a little more processing. Adding delay, smashing them, spring reverb, parallel compression, extreme eq, reamping, etc. I heard a suggestion from joel about getting better room sound by throwing up a cymbal or a sheet of metal on the far side of the room, and facing a mic at it for a sort of natural plate sound. I gotta try that.
Specifically regarding the bottom stnare mic...the Sunny Day Real Estate song "Days are Golden" on the "How it Feels..." album has a rad outro with a solo'd and crushed phasey bottom snare mic. Not much of a room mic...pretty much just the snares rattling and a bit of a feint kick sound. Musta been a super cardiod dynamic or something.
Also, I record drums in my living room....so you both can shut it.
"Writing good songs is hard. recording is easy. "
MoreSpaceEcho
MoreSpaceEcho
-
- zen recordist
- Posts: 6677
- Joined: Wed May 07, 2003 11:15 am
had a session recently where we tracked the drums in my control room, which isn't exactly small (17x21x13), but compared to the vast reverb wash that is my live room, it yields a much closer, tighter sound. which is what this record was calling for.
anyway, i still had good luck with my default omnis on the floor a few feet in front of the kit. also had interesting results putting the omnis up against the walls BEHIND my 703 panels. that sound was obviously a lot more diffuse than the mics on the floor sound.
i've done the omnis on the floor with a panel of 703 in front of them, that worked well too. more reverb/less direct sound from the kit that way.
reamping the snare works great. i usually have a gate/expander on the send to the speaker.
if you only have a small, crappy room to work in maybe try cardioids right up against the walls, facing away from the kit. my thinking being the cardioids will pick up less of the room sound, but you'll still be getting the reflections and some sustain.
the most common problem i've found with room mic tracks recorded elsewhere is just way too much treble. get those mics down LOOOOOOOWWWWWW. they'll still pick up the cymbals just fine.
anyway, i still had good luck with my default omnis on the floor a few feet in front of the kit. also had interesting results putting the omnis up against the walls BEHIND my 703 panels. that sound was obviously a lot more diffuse than the mics on the floor sound.
i've done the omnis on the floor with a panel of 703 in front of them, that worked well too. more reverb/less direct sound from the kit that way.
reamping the snare works great. i usually have a gate/expander on the send to the speaker.
if you only have a small, crappy room to work in maybe try cardioids right up against the walls, facing away from the kit. my thinking being the cardioids will pick up less of the room sound, but you'll still be getting the reflections and some sustain.
the most common problem i've found with room mic tracks recorded elsewhere is just way too much treble. get those mics down LOOOOOOOWWWWWW. they'll still pick up the cymbals just fine.
I record drums in this room, which is relatively small. Lately I've been mounting a boom stand actually on that piano with the top down, and use an Avenson STO-2 pointed straight up at the ceiling approx. 6-7' from the floor going into a Sytek pre.
While mixing I'll delay that mic (because it's fairly close to the kit, I go as far as 120 samples) and have been digging the PSP Oldtimer as a room smasher.
While mixing I'll delay that mic (because it's fairly close to the kit, I go as far as 120 samples) and have been digging the PSP Oldtimer as a room smasher.
-
- zen recordist
- Posts: 6677
- Joined: Wed May 07, 2003 11:15 am
couple other thoughts:
don't hit 'em that hard. wailing on drums in a big room is great, it gets the room going and is the sound you want. wailing on them in a small room just overwhelms it. drums played at conversational volume can sound totally huge in a mix.
leave the snare ringier than you might otherwise. in the big room i've been tending towards a drier snare, because the reverb fills it out nicely, and too much ring can be kind of overbearing. can occasionally be amazing though if the snare's tuned really perfectly for the song. anyway in a smaller room you're not going to have the reverb lengthening the snare so the ring can work well instead.
don't hit 'em that hard. wailing on drums in a big room is great, it gets the room going and is the sound you want. wailing on them in a small room just overwhelms it. drums played at conversational volume can sound totally huge in a mix.
leave the snare ringier than you might otherwise. in the big room i've been tending towards a drier snare, because the reverb fills it out nicely, and too much ring can be kind of overbearing. can occasionally be amazing though if the snare's tuned really perfectly for the song. anyway in a smaller room you're not going to have the reverb lengthening the snare so the ring can work well instead.
Totally agree. Cymbals especially can sound really nasty in a small room. My drumming technique for recording and playing shows has evolved into two different beasts, whereas I'm approaching the cymbals and kick more delicately while recording. The snare and toms don't seem to mind the small room as much thoughMoreSpaceEcho wrote:don't hit 'em that hard. wailing on drums in a big room is great, it gets the room going and is the sound you want. wailing on them in a small room just overwhelms it. drums played at conversational volume can sound totally huge in a mix.
-
- zen recordist
- Posts: 6677
- Joined: Wed May 07, 2003 11:15 am
- Ryan Silva
- tinnitus
- Posts: 1229
- Joined: Sat Aug 07, 2004 6:46 pm
- Location: San Francisco
-
- zen recordist
- Posts: 7494
- Joined: Tue Jun 01, 2004 10:30 pm
- Location: Bloomington IL
- Contact:
I'm pretty lucky, drums love my room and my room loves drums. My 70% of the time room set up is 4050s in omni on straight stands at their lowest, about waist high, equal distance from the BD. But I've done a ton of things to get great room sounds.
Last night I had a live with audience in studio recording. 2 artists alternating sets. I taped my MC012s (again omni) on the ledge over the booth. They sounded fantastic for the performance and the applause and sing alongs sound GIANT!
Last night I had a live with audience in studio recording. 2 artists alternating sets. I taped my MC012s (again omni) on the ledge over the booth. They sounded fantastic for the performance and the applause and sing alongs sound GIANT!
-
- steve albini likes it
- Posts: 327
- Joined: Sat May 19, 2007 12:33 pm
- Location: kentucky
- Contact:
I have to record drums IN the bathtub
these are my bands and my studio
http://www.myspace.com/metatron
http://www.myspace.com/thelionaudio
http://www.myspace.com/throneoflions
http://www.myspace.com/metatron
http://www.myspace.com/thelionaudio
http://www.myspace.com/throneoflions
- jgimbel
- carpal tunnel
- Posts: 1688
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 1:51 pm
- Location: Philadelphia, PA
- Contact:
My space is not what I'd call an ideal space to record in. Basement with low ceilings, but the ceiling is the floor joists from the above floor, with plastic sheeting stapled up so all the dust in this old house from the floor above doesn't fall in the space when people walk on the floor above. I've got 1/4 of the basement too, so I've got two walls (the corner of the basement), but the other two "walls" are two bookshelves on the short side, and a couch, dresser, and cement column on the other. Not ideal, though the lack of parallel walls stops bad reflections. It's on the dead side down here.
To get a bit more of a "live room" sound in here, I put up big wood panels on the long wall (which have guitar hangers on them too). The improvement was subtle, but there. One thing I do when I want big room sound though, since putting a FOK mic up doesn't sound much different here than an overhead, is put a mic or two (usually a 4050 in omni, or two SDCs) upstairs, directly above where the drums are. I get a really massive room sound that is very convincing to sound like I'm in a really nice sized room. And because the roominess is from the fact that the sound is passing through a floor and not purely distance, I never have to do any shifting in the time to compensate for a delay.
This weekend I had a band recording here but other folks were around, so I couldn't put a mic upstairs. I put a mic at the other end of the basement near the top of the stairs, by the basement door. That worked easily well. It took me a few years of getting less-than-desirable drum sounds before thinking to try room mics elsewhere in the house, and now it's the way to go when I need big drum sounds in my small space.
To get a bit more of a "live room" sound in here, I put up big wood panels on the long wall (which have guitar hangers on them too). The improvement was subtle, but there. One thing I do when I want big room sound though, since putting a FOK mic up doesn't sound much different here than an overhead, is put a mic or two (usually a 4050 in omni, or two SDCs) upstairs, directly above where the drums are. I get a really massive room sound that is very convincing to sound like I'm in a really nice sized room. And because the roominess is from the fact that the sound is passing through a floor and not purely distance, I never have to do any shifting in the time to compensate for a delay.
This weekend I had a band recording here but other folks were around, so I couldn't put a mic upstairs. I put a mic at the other end of the basement near the top of the stairs, by the basement door. That worked easily well. It took me a few years of getting less-than-desirable drum sounds before thinking to try room mics elsewhere in the house, and now it's the way to go when I need big drum sounds in my small space.
My first new personal album in four years - pay what you want - http://jessegimbel.bandcamp.com
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 79 guests