Ok, well I'll make this one my last post on it. Sorry if I didn't realize you were trying to be playful - seemed pretty snide to me. Secondly, you say my criticism was unwarranted - why, just because you disagree with it? Third, I don't need any points to say what I like or don't like. If you respect those other's remarks just because they hang around here more than I do then that's fine, but at the end of the day it's all just opinions.Gregg Juke wrote:Yeah, I probably shouldn't have said anything at all, playful or not, but I was apparently right in surmising a bit of a "I'm the Man" attitude in this cat's response, and I had a moment and got all protector-y and whatnot, which then opened me up to this completely unwarranted criticism ...
Sorry I stuck my neck out to shoot down some high-flying BS, because, well, Nick is entitled to his opinion, even if it's sometimes harsh, because he has the experience and the knowledge, and the history here at the TOMB, to back it up-- and as Ubertar said, sometimes this is a tough place to post finished material. But Gelatelli? How about earning some community-participation points before spouting off about how great you are and how much better you could do it?!? Seriously??? End rant. GJ
I did a very positive review of a song by a guy named Guitar Jeff - if you type in his name you will find it, but unfortunately the song is no longer available - a while ago. Loved the song - best I've ever heard on any message board. Just tons of feeling - not just making music to some kind of formula - and very personal. I was surprised he would even reveal such personal stuff. Also, great engineering, great production, just plain great. Yet still I believe I did give him one or two critic points. With you, although I'm not a fan of your style, I think your band is good, but your lyrics need tweaking - that's my opinion. The way you are acting, I'm thinking that you didn't really understand my comment, so you took it in a negative way, but there was no need to jump to that conclusion. You can do whatever you want with your lyrics, my friend, and I have no interest in them beyond the comments that I made. So, if you want to call my comments BS, then that's fine with me, but I won't apologize for speaking out what I feel.
Ok, Mr. moderator, NOW you can take it off!