Recording guitars direct: give it to me.
- inverseroom
- on a wing and a prayer
- Posts: 5031
- Joined: Wed May 07, 2003 8:37 am
- Location: Ithaca, NY
- Contact:
Recording guitars direct: give it to me.
OK, if you're gonna tell me to go buy an amp and mic it, you can just go poop yourself. Because I do indeed have a nice recording amp and would love to mic it all the time. But I record in a noisy environment and 70% of the time don't have that choice...and when I do have a moment of silence, I usually use it for vocals or acoustic guitar.
So what I'd like to know is how you all get good sounding electric guitar tracks while recording direct. Here are the methods I've used and like, but found somewhat lacking.
1) Sansamp PSA-1. Great tones, but the cab sim never did it for me. I sold it after a while, and miss it sometimes. I'm actually thinking about re-buying it.
2) Vox Tonelab. I like the cab sims quite a lot! But it's noisy, and not a good kind of noise...and I'm never satisfied with the mids. Nevertheless, it's my main go-to guitar thingy.
3) Software. I've done a few tracks by playing clean through the Hamptone, then processing in the box, mostly with FreeAmp 2, a terrific software amp/fx suite. Sounds pretty decent but it's not much fun.
4) Zoom G2. A shockingly good pedal for $99. But the amp models are few, the choices narrow, and it's always over at my bandmate's house anyway.
And here are the methods I'm thinking about trying...
1) Sansamp classic. Never tried it. Does it do stuff the PSA-1 doesn't? Is the cab sim good? It doesn't have to be "realistic," just GOOD.
2) PodXT. I've never so much as tried the thing, but I have heard the Pod has gotten quite excellent in the latest version.
If you get good sounds with directly recorded guitars, how do you do it? I should add I have lots of nice effects pedals to put in front of the amp model, so I don't need a solution that has a zillion effects attached to it.
Thanks all
John
So what I'd like to know is how you all get good sounding electric guitar tracks while recording direct. Here are the methods I've used and like, but found somewhat lacking.
1) Sansamp PSA-1. Great tones, but the cab sim never did it for me. I sold it after a while, and miss it sometimes. I'm actually thinking about re-buying it.
2) Vox Tonelab. I like the cab sims quite a lot! But it's noisy, and not a good kind of noise...and I'm never satisfied with the mids. Nevertheless, it's my main go-to guitar thingy.
3) Software. I've done a few tracks by playing clean through the Hamptone, then processing in the box, mostly with FreeAmp 2, a terrific software amp/fx suite. Sounds pretty decent but it's not much fun.
4) Zoom G2. A shockingly good pedal for $99. But the amp models are few, the choices narrow, and it's always over at my bandmate's house anyway.
And here are the methods I'm thinking about trying...
1) Sansamp classic. Never tried it. Does it do stuff the PSA-1 doesn't? Is the cab sim good? It doesn't have to be "realistic," just GOOD.
2) PodXT. I've never so much as tried the thing, but I have heard the Pod has gotten quite excellent in the latest version.
If you get good sounds with directly recorded guitars, how do you do it? I should add I have lots of nice effects pedals to put in front of the amp model, so I don't need a solution that has a zillion effects attached to it.
Thanks all
John
- RodC
- dead but not forgotten
- Posts: 2039
- Joined: Thu Dec 30, 2004 8:53 pm
- Location: Right outside the door
- Contact:
Well I always like to reamp, but you could also try a few other things.
I like the POD XT but steer clear of the presets, I havnt done a lot with it but I have heard some good stuff.
I like to be different. Get yourself a nice guitar preamp and use some cab simulators, either software or hardware.
What about a hot plate and use the line out of it? Its not the same as micing the speaker but at least you can capture some of the poweramp tube sound.
I like the POD XT but steer clear of the presets, I havnt done a lot with it but I have heard some good stuff.
I like to be different. Get yourself a nice guitar preamp and use some cab simulators, either software or hardware.
What about a hot plate and use the line out of it? Its not the same as micing the speaker but at least you can capture some of the poweramp tube sound.
'Well, I've been to one world fair, a picnic, and a rodeo, and that's the stupidest thing I ever heard come over a set of earphones'
http://www.beyondsanityproductions.com
http://www.myspace.com/beyondsanity
http://www.beyondsanityproductions.com
http://www.myspace.com/beyondsanity
-
- buyin' a studio
- Posts: 928
- Joined: Sat Jun 07, 2003 1:16 pm
- Location: Denver, CO
- Contact:
I used to own a PSA-1 and I sold it. I think it makes a nice preamp going into a real amp and speaker, but I didn't really like it for direct.
I have a PodXT Live right now, and I think it's pretty good. I've used it on records for clean tones. I really like it for bass, too. You can now buy the bass models and install them on your guitar PodXT to turn it into a "Bass PodXT Lite". I definitely agree with RodC about avoiding the presets and rolling your own. There are so many frickin' choices that it might take a while to find the sounds that do it for you, but it's worth it.
I have a PodXT Live right now, and I think it's pretty good. I've used it on records for clean tones. I really like it for bass, too. You can now buy the bass models and install them on your guitar PodXT to turn it into a "Bass PodXT Lite". I definitely agree with RodC about avoiding the presets and rolling your own. There are so many frickin' choices that it might take a while to find the sounds that do it for you, but it's worth it.
- inverseroom
- on a wing and a prayer
- Posts: 5031
- Joined: Wed May 07, 2003 8:37 am
- Location: Ithaca, NY
- Contact:
Not in my experience with it, though that was with the first pod edition. Didn't hear any difference between the kidney bean and the 19-incher.inverseroom wrote:Nah, I never use presets...I really enjoy twiddling knobs until something good comes out.
Is the rackmount Pod "better"? Worth all the extra dough?
-
- buyin' a studio
- Posts: 928
- Joined: Sat Jun 07, 2003 1:16 pm
- Location: Denver, CO
- Contact:
The rack version gives you balanced XLR and some other I/O goodies, but the models and effects are exactly the same as the bean. Save your money.
OTOH, the XT Live is worth the extra cash if you gig with it because it's a floorboard design with switches and a pedal, which is very handy for live situations. Otherwise, you gotta buy the bean and a separate pedalboard. It's nice to have it all in one.
OTOH, the XT Live is worth the extra cash if you gig with it because it's a floorboard design with switches and a pedal, which is very handy for live situations. Otherwise, you gotta buy the bean and a separate pedalboard. It's nice to have it all in one.
- rhythm ranch
- mixes from purgatory
- Posts: 2793
- Joined: Wed May 07, 2003 8:45 pm
- Location: Corrales, NM
A good friend and life-long guitarist had a Pod for years and really liked it. Easy to take to small gigs, small apartment rehearsals, sounded good, very tweakable. When the Pod XT came out, he sold the old Pod and got the XT. At first, he was frustrated with it; after a couple of months he started liking it quite a bit. He said that he felt like the XT had better algorithms and was more like the amps it was modeling. It took a little more work to get a sound you felt was just right and all your own - just like when working with a real amp.
- Quest Poetics
- suffering 'studio suck'
- Posts: 405
- Joined: Tue Aug 19, 2003 8:16 pm
- Location: Vancouver BC
- Contact:
Get a software emulator...I use amplitube and dont necessarily use the distortion on the software, instead use your pedals into the amp model w/ the distortion turned off (with in the software) I"ve actually have had way better results w/ that setup rather than any pod / outboard emulator....
Peace
Peace
www.rhymeandmelody.com
Podcast where we review gear as well as drop Guitars / Beatboxing / Freestyle rhyme one week and the following episode you hear the fully produced track.
Peace and keep recording!!!
Podcast where we review gear as well as drop Guitars / Beatboxing / Freestyle rhyme one week and the following episode you hear the fully produced track.
Peace and keep recording!!!
-
- dead but not forgotten
- Posts: 2037
- Joined: Wed Sep 22, 2004 10:22 am
- Location: Ramah, New Mexico
FWIW I like the Toneport UX2 quite a bit and use it to re-amp with but it also sounds pretty cool as a DI if you route the analog outputs through a Pro VLA to add some analog color. The Toneport has some of the XT technology and some of the Vetta models as well and the console emulations are fun, as is the mic modeller and pre-delay feature on the reverb. Very useful little tool that's incredibly inexpensive IMO. The GUI interface is great great fun and totally cool. It's an addictive little gadget.
BTW, the toneport analog outputs routed into a tube 4-track RTR sounds quite convincing.
BTW, the toneport analog outputs routed into a tube 4-track RTR sounds quite convincing.
"The mushroom states its own position very clearly. It says, "I require the nervous system of a mammal. Do you have one handy?" Terrence McKenna
- inverseroom
- on a wing and a prayer
- Posts: 5031
- Joined: Wed May 07, 2003 8:37 am
- Location: Ithaca, NY
- Contact:
Toneport, no shit? I should try it out.
I'm actually very satisfied with my method of getting sounds into the computer. And I do indeed have a Pro VLA, and when I've done guitars direct, they indeed have gone through several pieces of tube gear. So this makes sense, as does Sound Campaign's idea. I really do recommend FreeAmp 2...version 3 should be out before too long, in fact. It's freeware, a VST.
I shouldn't be getting hung up on this stuff...I feel like this kind of thing is a much lower priority than a good song and a good performance...I mean I'd rather have a wonderful solo poorly recorded than a careful and calculated one that sounds great...but there's that little voice in the back of my head that says I can have it all...
I'm actually very satisfied with my method of getting sounds into the computer. And I do indeed have a Pro VLA, and when I've done guitars direct, they indeed have gone through several pieces of tube gear. So this makes sense, as does Sound Campaign's idea. I really do recommend FreeAmp 2...version 3 should be out before too long, in fact. It's freeware, a VST.
I shouldn't be getting hung up on this stuff...I feel like this kind of thing is a much lower priority than a good song and a good performance...I mean I'd rather have a wonderful solo poorly recorded than a careful and calculated one that sounds great...but there's that little voice in the back of my head that says I can have it all...
-
- ghost haunting audio students
- Posts: 3490
- Joined: Wed May 07, 2003 11:11 pm
- Location: Saint Paul, MN
I own both a SansAmp original and Pod XT Live....
I actually use both as a speaker sim, and you can definitely make them work.
The key (for me) has been getting a good, relatively transparent pedal compressor. For my SansAmp, I use my Maxon compressor. On the Pod XT, I program a good compressor (there are several to choose from).
They give you the extra feel that you expect from playing through a speaker... a slight give or pushback. It's made all the difference.
When recording, I DI them through a Groove Tubes Ditto box into a RNP. Works just fine.
The SansAmp takes pedals really well...especially distortion and fuzz.
I actually use both as a speaker sim, and you can definitely make them work.
The key (for me) has been getting a good, relatively transparent pedal compressor. For my SansAmp, I use my Maxon compressor. On the Pod XT, I program a good compressor (there are several to choose from).
They give you the extra feel that you expect from playing through a speaker... a slight give or pushback. It's made all the difference.
When recording, I DI them through a Groove Tubes Ditto box into a RNP. Works just fine.
The SansAmp takes pedals really well...especially distortion and fuzz.
JOhn, if I want to run clean, I'll just run directly into a preamp that has a 1/4" jack. Sounds great imo.
If I want noise, then an outboard preamp like the Voodoo labs or Boogie Quad etc work great.
Then get a Lil labs re-amp'r thing when you have time or its day time or whatever, and reamp and mic it if you feel you need to. Also, you can record a clean signal directly through the mic preamp, then when you re-amp, you can use your pedals to get whatever.
If I want noise, then an outboard preamp like the Voodoo labs or Boogie Quad etc work great.
Then get a Lil labs re-amp'r thing when you have time or its day time or whatever, and reamp and mic it if you feel you need to. Also, you can record a clean signal directly through the mic preamp, then when you re-amp, you can use your pedals to get whatever.
- joelkriske
- gettin' sounds
- Posts: 134
- Joined: Tue Feb 03, 2004 2:20 am
- Location: chicago IL
- Contact:
-
- takin' a dinner break
- Posts: 185
- Joined: Tue Dec 09, 2003 2:02 pm
- Location: Madison WI
- Contact:
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 101 guests