how to record a band live
- Babaluma
- suffering 'studio suck'
- Posts: 447
- Joined: Sun Dec 12, 2004 6:42 am
- Location: Milan, Italy
- Contact:
how to record a band live
please forgive the newbie questions
i've been making programmed electronic ambient and techno music by myself for the last 15 years, but i want to start branching out into tracking and mixing live bands, which is a completely different cup of tea.
i like the steve albini ethos of trying as hard as possible to capture the live sound of the band. i work at a japanese girls high school and will probably start out by recording these punk/indie/rock bands.
my questions relate to the specifics/logistics of achieving that live sound.
i understand how to mic the drums/bass amp/guitar amp etc, but i am wondering about the vocalist. i want to avoid multitracking if possible, but i also want to get as much seperation as possible for later ease of mixing.
do i just put the vocalist through a PA and mic that? what about spill into the other mics? do i put the voalist in a vocal booth where the other band members can see her and get everyone to wear headphones and set up a headphone mix for them all so that they can hear her? doesn't that distract from "rocking out"?
or would it just be easier to ask the band to play first and then get the vocals down later?
how do the pros do it?
thanks in advance for any ideas,
gregg
i've been making programmed electronic ambient and techno music by myself for the last 15 years, but i want to start branching out into tracking and mixing live bands, which is a completely different cup of tea.
i like the steve albini ethos of trying as hard as possible to capture the live sound of the band. i work at a japanese girls high school and will probably start out by recording these punk/indie/rock bands.
my questions relate to the specifics/logistics of achieving that live sound.
i understand how to mic the drums/bass amp/guitar amp etc, but i am wondering about the vocalist. i want to avoid multitracking if possible, but i also want to get as much seperation as possible for later ease of mixing.
do i just put the vocalist through a PA and mic that? what about spill into the other mics? do i put the voalist in a vocal booth where the other band members can see her and get everyone to wear headphones and set up a headphone mix for them all so that they can hear her? doesn't that distract from "rocking out"?
or would it just be easier to ask the band to play first and then get the vocals down later?
how do the pros do it?
thanks in advance for any ideas,
gregg
- Babaluma
- suffering 'studio suck'
- Posts: 447
- Joined: Sun Dec 12, 2004 6:42 am
- Location: Milan, Italy
- Contact:
thanks, that's a fantastic suggestion, hadn't considered that at all!Danly wrote:when i record my band practices, we do 4 tracks. 1 mic on the guitar amp, 1 mic on the bass amp, 1 mic on the drums, and an aux send (line out) from the p.a.
this setup is great for me because we're limited in track space and can get two singers with 2 different mics on to one track.
- Babaluma
- suffering 'studio suck'
- Posts: 447
- Joined: Sun Dec 12, 2004 6:42 am
- Location: Milan, Italy
- Contact:
it's great!stuntbutt wrote:I can't stop thinking about working at a Japanese girl's high school.
there's a "soft rock" after school club, but they are all more like heavy rock/indie/ska/punk bands. there are about 10 of them. i'm an english teacher, but am hoping to offer my recording services for free once i've got the equipment together, hopefully early next year.
at the moment i'm just trying to get my head around the logistics of it all.
-
- gettin' sounds
- Posts: 126
- Joined: Mon Nov 08, 2004 9:38 am
- Location: Portland, OR
- Contact:
Room mics can be cool, if you have the space for them. If you're going 2-track and can mix live, then throw up a stereo pair, along with whatever you can pull from the board. do you mic the amps and drums into the live mix regularly?
get some good isolation headphones to get a good idea of what's going on. if it were me, I'd try to do multitrack to give me the most options when mixing.
have fun!
get some good isolation headphones to get a good idea of what's going on. if it were me, I'd try to do multitrack to give me the most options when mixing.
have fun!
Ask the band how they want to do it. If they don't mind using a vocal booth or singing through a P.A. then try that and see how it sounds.
This is what I do and usually they say they want to do everything live. Then when we listen to that they realize there is too much cymbal bleed in the vocals and we overdub those (I have 1 room, no booth). Then often I suggest guitar overdubs if it's a three piece and we decide whether or not we like those, etc.
There's definately no 'pro' way to do it, there's a million ways to do it.
This is what I do and usually they say they want to do everything live. Then when we listen to that they realize there is too much cymbal bleed in the vocals and we overdub those (I have 1 room, no booth). Then often I suggest guitar overdubs if it's a three piece and we decide whether or not we like those, etc.
There's definately no 'pro' way to do it, there's a million ways to do it.
It depends on how commercial a sound you're going for. I've done several projects where we've recorded the band together to get a live feel but my clients want the recording to sound upfront and professional which means that I pretty much have to isolate the guitars and bass from the drums to get the separation I need to achieve that kind of sound.
I record in my basement studio but I have three rooms where I can isolate the guitars and bass if necessary. I put the drums in the main room and the guitar cabs in other rooms. I close-mic the guitar cabs. Usually we run the bass through a Sansamp Bass Driver so we don't need a separate room for that.
All the players are in the main room with the drummer so the band can see each other and maintain the vibe. I have several pairs of Vic Firth isolation headphones so each band member can hear what's going on.
I've never tried to record vocals with the instrument performance. I think that's just asking too much. I record the vocals later and I virtually always record several takes and comp the best parts together. The vocal is so important that it's just not realistic to expect a young singer to nail it in one take.
I have a couple songs on my Myspace page that were done this way if you'd like to check them out. On the player to the right play the bottom song, the one by Shanghai Shanghai. The other player on the left also has a song by the same group. Mudshark Studios
I record in my basement studio but I have three rooms where I can isolate the guitars and bass if necessary. I put the drums in the main room and the guitar cabs in other rooms. I close-mic the guitar cabs. Usually we run the bass through a Sansamp Bass Driver so we don't need a separate room for that.
All the players are in the main room with the drummer so the band can see each other and maintain the vibe. I have several pairs of Vic Firth isolation headphones so each band member can hear what's going on.
I've never tried to record vocals with the instrument performance. I think that's just asking too much. I record the vocals later and I virtually always record several takes and comp the best parts together. The vocal is so important that it's just not realistic to expect a young singer to nail it in one take.
I have a couple songs on my Myspace page that were done this way if you'd like to check them out. On the player to the right play the bottom song, the one by Shanghai Shanghai. The other player on the left also has a song by the same group. Mudshark Studios
- Babaluma
- suffering 'studio suck'
- Posts: 447
- Joined: Sun Dec 12, 2004 6:42 am
- Location: Milan, Italy
- Contact:
thanks for the hints.stevebozz wrote:do you mic the amps and drums into the live mix regularly?
get some good isolation headphones to get a good idea of what's going on. if it were me, I'd try to do multitrack to give me the most options when mixing.
have fun!
as i said, this is all new to me and academic at the mo!
i want to be able to record the "authentic" live sound of the band, but also have as much seperation as possible for later mixing.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 28 guests